Picture a container coming off a train in Chicago, headed for a different railroad on the other side of town. Today, someone has to drive it there. That someone is a drayage driver, and the move is called a crosstown. The proposed (Union Pacific) UP–Norfolk Southern merger is aimed squarely at making it unnecessary.
Why Chicago Is Where This Gets Real
No Class I railroad owns track that runs coast to coast. As Mark-it Express owner Tony Apa explains, freight moving from Miami to Portland rides one railroad to Chicago, gets trucked across town to another railroad, and then continues west. Drayage carriers get paid to make that handoff.
The proposed $85 billion merger would combine UP’s western network with NS’s eastern one. It’s currently under review by the Surface Transportation Board.
What the Projections Say
According to a study reported by Commercial Carrier Journal, Chicago handles roughly one million drayage shipments a year. The study projects the merger could eliminate 250,000 to 500,000 local truck trips and cut 5 million to 15 million local truck-miles annually.
The railroads’ own filing says the combined company would convert more than 2 million truckloads from long-haul trucking to rail.
Those are projections, not results. Treat them that way.
What We’d Be Lying About If We Skipped It
We run drayage in Chicago, and crosstowns are part of that world. A merger designed to remove them aims to eliminate cross-town rubber-tire transfers, which would erase hundreds of thousands of local trucking jobs and create, if not a railroad monopoly, a serious reduction in competition.
But the trucker is usually the last to feel a change like this. Tony’s view is that even if the deal goes through, it could be five to ten years before drayage feels it. There are too many questions to answer first.
The Questions Still on the Table
The railroads don’t operate the same way everywhere. Some of Norfolk Southern’s Chicago-area facilities are grounded, and some are mounted, and that difference shapes how a driver gets a chassis and a container. How UP and NS would integrate those terminals, and what happens to flip fees, is the kind of detail that decides what a move costs.
CCJ also notes that analysts expect the projected savings to depend on actual operational integration. People will be watching whether those savings become lower rates for shippers, and whether the railroads make enforceable commitments on terminal access.
Owner Tony Apa has a broader concern too. If this leaves two transcontinental railroads, is that enough competition? His honest answer: he doesn’t know.
What Shippers Can Do Right Now
Nothing changes on your next Chicago move. But a few things are worth doing before anyone else asks:
Ask your carrier how they’d handle a changing Chicago rail landscape, not just what they’d charge. Keep your eye on landed cost rather than the line-haul rate alone. And pay attention to how UP and NS plan to run their terminals, because that’s where the real impact will show up.
We’ll keep watching it, and we’ll tell you what we see.
If the crosstown goes away in five or ten years, does your carrier have a plan, or just a rate?